Home
Resources
TCPA reference library
What does Justice Kavanaugh have to do with SMS?
Enforcement and cases

What does Justice Kavanaugh have to do with SMS?

2021 · 3 min
Published 2021. Retained for reference. Not current legal guidance.
Carrier registration, consent expectations, and enforcement have changed since this was written. For how Tatango handles consent, opt-outs, send timing, and registration today, see compliance and deliverability. For your obligations, ask counsel. Compliance and deliverability

In October 2018, Justice Brett Kavanaugh was sworn in as a United States Supreme Court Justice, a position that could have a lasting impact on the future of mobile marketing and the role of regulatory agencies in the US. In the video above, Tatango CEO Derek Johnson discusses possible future changes with TCPA attorney David Carter. If you prefer to read, see the summary below.

The Regulatory Role and the TCPA

For any company using SMS messaging, following the rules outlined in the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) is vital. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) applies and enforces these laws that are a central part of the mobile marketing industry. In recent history, regulatory agencies like the FCC have interpreted how the law is enforced within their arena. They can uphold the letter of the law while shifting the real-world outcomes. This power had become broader over time. 

This uncertainty can be difficult for companies working under these laws. If a brand can’t count on a consistent and lasting interpretation of laws, it’s hard to expand and plan confidently. Should the courts defer to these regulatory agencies whenever a vague issue needs definition? This practice is known as a deference doctrine. Justice Kavanaugh’s role in the Supreme Court could lead to the permanent elimination of this doctrine.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh and the TCPA

In his time on the Court of Appeals, Justice Kavanaugh showed a desire to shift the balance of power between the courts and agencies like the FCC. His influence on the Supreme Court may lead to challenges and changes to deference doctrines. His past opinions indicate that Kavanaugh believes political whim shouldn’t dictate how the same words are applied. 

A Supreme Court verdict on this issue could have a lasting impact on all regulatory agencies, making their power more focused and narrow. Justice Kavanaugh is also tuned into the dynamics between the FCC and the TCPA, as evidenced by his past decisions on the TCPA. With that in mind, going forward, we may see a shift in how the mobile marketing industry operates. 

Looking Ahead

These changes could be coming with the recent shifts in the Supreme Court’s leanings. The “accordion effect” of the interpretation of laws being pulled back and forth by each political administration is unsustainable and can negatively impact growth within many areas of the American economy. If this issue comes before the current Supreme Court, a decision could change the role of regulation. It did: in 2024 the Supreme Court ended Chevron deference in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, and in 2025, in an opinion by Justice Kavanaugh, it held in McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates v. McKesson that district courts are not bound by the FCC’s interpretations of the TCPA. 

Uncertainty makes operating a business challenging, especially for brands in the technology industry. As technology continues to evolve and innovation expands what’s possible, laws need to be updated efficiently to avoid limiting that expansion. 

Need Help Understanding TCPA Regulations for Text Message Marketing?

Tatango has been an industry leader since 2007. Our text message marketing platform offers tools to help ensure your campaigns comply with TCPA requirements. Contact our sales and support team today.

Customer success

A named Customer Success Manager for every account.

Every account gets a Customer Success Manager you can call, who partners with your team from onboarding through election night to build effective campaigns and raise the ROI on every send. Our CS team is the part of Tatango customers review highest.

Fast, guided onboarding

Your CSM gets your numbers registered, integrations connected, and first send out on your timeline, then stays on the account.

Number registration · Integrations · First send

Campaign strategy and compliance guidance

Message cadence, segment strategy, ask amounts, consent and opt-out setup, quiet hours, and registration, reviewed with you before launch and as the cycle changes. Guidance, not legal advice.

Cadence · Segments · Consent · Carrier rules

Campaign-cycle coverage

Extended support through deadline nights, debates, and election week, with a person who already knows your program picking up the phone.

Deadline nights · Debates · Election week

Trust and security

Trust that holds up to scrutiny.

Security, privacy, and compliance controls audited independently and built into the platform, so a committee treasurer, compliance counsel, or data lead can sign off quickly.

SOC 2 Type II

Independently audited security controls, with a clean opinion for 2025.

HIPAA

HIPAA-ready controls and BAAs for organizations that handle protected health information alongside political or advocacy work.

TCPA controls

Consent capture, automatic opt-out handling, list scrubbing before every send, and exportable audit history.

10DLC and short code registration

Registered with The Campaign Registry and carriers before your first send.

Encryption and access

Encryption in transit and at rest, role-based access, and audit logging on every action.

Privacy and data handling

Data retention controls, isolated opt-out lists per organization, and a published trust center.

Read the trust center

See it on your program.

A 30-minute walkthrough tailored to fundraising, mobilization, or both.