Home
Resources
TCPA reference library
Case review: Edelsberg v. Vroom
Enforcement and cases

Case review: Edelsberg v. Vroom

2021 · 5 min
Case summary written in 2021. The outcome may have changed since.
This summarises litigation as it stood when it was written. Cases settle, get appealed, and get decided after the fact, so treat this as background on how a TCPA argument was framed rather than as the current state of the law or of this matter. Check the docket, and ask counsel before relying on any of it. How the obligations are structured

Can a single text message land you in legal trouble? Yes, depending on the message and whether you have the recipient’s consent to send it.

This article looks at the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) court case Edelsberg v. Vroom and what marketers can learn from it.

About Edelsberg v. Vroom

One afternoon in 2016, Mark Edelsberg posted an ad on craigslist selling his mom's 2010 Prius. In the ad, he included his cell phone number and invited potential buyers to send offers. Two days after publishing the ad, he received a text from Vroom, an online used car dealer, that said:

“Hi Mark, I am Scott at Vroom. I saw you listed your Prius online & can make an offer but need you to fill out a few more details (takes 4 min) http://go.vroom.com/syc/6C9179. Text STOP to Quit”

Mr. Edelsberg didn't open the link in the text. Instead, he sued Vroom for allegedly messaging him without consent, breaking the TCPA regulations.

A Lawsuit Over One Text Message?

The text itself probably didn't bother Edelsberg that much, but there were other incentives. If he was mad and wanted to sue Vroom over the single text, he could have taken the company to small claims court. If he won, he'd receive between $500 and $1,500 for what would likely amount to a significant amount of time spent in court. That is a lot of hassle over one text message for as little as $500.

Instead of going to small claims court, Edelsberg became the main witness in a class-action lawsuit. A class action aims to represent a class of people. In this case, the suit represented the other consumers who received similar text messages from Vroom. Since the lawyers in a class action represent thousands of people, they stand to win a lot more money if they succeed in court.

Given such a significant potential gain, many lawyers actively seek plaintiffs like Edelsberg with billboards, TV ads, and even text messages. Typically, these lawyers promise to make the process as frictionless as possible, requiring plaintiffs to appear in court only when absolutely necessary. They point to the potential earnings from $1,000 to $10,000 in addition to what everyone else in the class makes from winning the case.

The Outcome of Edelsberg v. Vroom

There were two key issues in this case: 

  1. Did Vroom have consent to send this message?
  2. If so, what level of consent was required to contact Edelsberg in this way? (In other words, did Vroom need express written consent, or was consent implied when he posted his number on craigslist?)

An FCC rule in place for over 15 years swung the case in favor of Vroom. The rule states that when a person makes their phone number available for a particular commercial purpose, they’re giving prior express consent for businesses to contact them about that area of business. So, if an individual provides their phone number to a bank, the bank can call them about business related to the bank. However, the bank can't contact the person about something unrelated to that area of business, such as selling ice cream sandwiches.

Since Mr. Edelsberg listed his phone number publicly on craigslist seeking offers from potential buyers, Vroom had permission to contact him, though only about making that offer. In the end, the judge ruled that even though Vroom didn't send an offer, the link the company sent was for the sole purpose of getting more information on his car before sending an offer.

If the text Vroom sent had instead said something to the effect of "Hey! You should list your car on vroom.com!" The court would have likely seen that type of message as pure marketing because it isn't directly related to the business for which Mr. Edelsberg listed his phone number, so the lawsuit would have likely had a very different outcome.

Instead, the case was dismissed, and Mr. Edelsberg didn't receive any money.

Is Vroom in the Clear Now?

Vroom is and isn’t in the clear now. Because the company won this case, it would likely win a similar case in another state. So, other lawyers probably won’t try suing Vroom for the same type of behavior again.

However, if Vroom does face another lawsuit for the same type of behavior, say, in Texas or even in the Southern District of Florida again, a different judge could have a different opinion. 

What Text Message Marketers Can Learn

First, work with TCPA attorneys and SMS marketing providers like Tatango. Involve them in the process of designing your messaging campaigns rather than waiting until you’re facing a lawsuit. TCPA compliance also helps your campaigns succeed. If you're obtaining proper consent, and your recipients have indicated they want to hear from you, you'll get better results from your messages, and you'll be safe from costly lawsuits.

Every message a business sends isn’t necessarily a marketing message. Sometimes a message is informational. Be sure you obtain consent to send the types of messages you’re planning to send. 

Vroom's message upset at least one person. Even if a message is technically legal, some recipients may still consider it spam. To get the best results and reduce your unsubscribe rate, in addition to considering the legal ramifications of a campaign, always think about the consumer's experience of your brand.

Tatango Can Help You Meet TCPA Requirements and Avoid Lawsuits

Tatango has been an industry leader since 2007. Our text message marketing platform offers tools to help you meet TCPA consent requirements to reduce your risk of litigation. For help from our team of experts, contact us today to get started.

Customer success

A named Customer Success Manager for every account.

Every account gets a Customer Success Manager you can call, who partners with your team from onboarding through election night to build effective campaigns and raise the ROI on every send. Our CS team is the part of Tatango customers review highest.

Fast, guided onboarding

Your CSM gets your numbers registered, integrations connected, and first send out on your timeline, then stays on the account.

Number registration · Integrations · First send

Campaign strategy and compliance guidance

Message cadence, segment strategy, ask amounts, consent and opt-out setup, quiet hours, and registration, reviewed with you before launch and as the cycle changes. Guidance, not legal advice.

Cadence · Segments · Consent · Carrier rules

Campaign-cycle coverage

Extended support through deadline nights, debates, and election week, with a person who already knows your program picking up the phone.

Deadline nights · Debates · Election week

Trust and security

Trust that holds up to scrutiny.

Security, privacy, and compliance controls audited independently and built into the platform, so a committee treasurer, compliance counsel, or data lead can sign off quickly.

SOC 2 Type II

Independently audited security controls, with a clean opinion for 2025.

HIPAA

HIPAA-ready controls and BAAs for organizations that handle protected health information alongside political or advocacy work.

TCPA controls

Consent capture, automatic opt-out handling, list scrubbing before every send, and exportable audit history.

10DLC and short code registration

Registered with The Campaign Registry and carriers before your first send.

Encryption and access

Encryption in transit and at rest, role-based access, and audit logging on every action.

Privacy and data handling

Data retention controls, isolated opt-out lists per organization, and a published trust center.

Read the trust center

See it on your program.

A 30-minute walkthrough tailored to fundraising, mobilization, or both.