Home
Resources
TCPA reference library
Case review: Viggiano v. Kohl’s
Enforcement and cases

Case review: Viggiano v. Kohl’s

2021 · 3 min
Case summary written in 2021. The outcome may have changed since.
This summarises litigation as it stood when it was written. Cases settle, get appealed, and get decided after the fact, so treat this as background on how a TCPA argument was framed rather than as the current state of the law or of this matter. Check the docket, and ask counsel before relying on any of it. How the obligations are structured

Companies encourage consumers to opt in to text message marketing campaigns because they’re an easy and accessible way to keep consumers engaged and informed. Unfortunately, Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) cases have become one of the most common types of consumer protection litigation in federal courts. The TCPA requires that companies prove they offer consumers reasonable methods to opt out of communication AND that companies obtain written consent when consumers opt in. This post reviews Viggiano v. Kohl's Department Stores and offers strategies that can help text message marketers avoid litigation.

About Viggiano v. Kohl's Department Stores

Kohl's Department Stores is a national brand known for its shopping experience and the savings campaigns it offers consumers in stores, online, and through its mobile app. Plaintiff Amy Viggiano opted in to Kohl's text message marketing campaign, and after some time, decided she no longer wanted to receive text messages from the company. Viggiano tried to opt out with the following text messages:

"I’ve changed my mind and don’t want to receive these anymore.”

"Please don't send any further messages."

"I don't want these messages anymore. This is your last warning!"

Kohl's SMS platform replied, "Sorry, we don't understand. Reply, 'HELP' for help or, 'STOP' to cancel."

Viggiano filed a class-action lawsuit against Kohl’s due to alleged TCPA violations regarding the continued unwanted communication. Kohl's filed a motion to dismiss the case based upon providing reasonable means for Viggiano to opt out. The case was dismissed later that year.

Strategies to Help SMS Marketers Avoid Litigation

One of the most important things text message marketers can do to reduce their risk of litigation with disgruntled consumers is to make sure they’ve provided reasonable means for consumers to opt out. 

1. Communicate clearly in automated responses.

Most SMS platforms provide companies with 160 characters in automated responses to respond to consumers. Don't let those characters go to waste. Check out our detailed guide outlining what's required in an SMS opt-in confirmation message. Let consumers know that a software program is texting them. Use words such as HELP and STOP to ensure automatic responses are easy to understand. Be sure your message states that it’s an automated response (similar to no-reply emails). Use straightforward language with consumers in messages delivered by automated systems.

2. Keep thorough, pristine records.

The TCPA places the burden of proof on the defendant, which is you. Keep a visual library of the consumer's experience from beginning to end. Take photos of the opt-in process, including the call-to-action methods placed in stores, emails, and flyers, as well as all messages sent to the consumer during the campaign and the opt-out stage. The statute of limitations is up to four years, but it's a best practice to keep all records, even records of discontinued campaigns. 

3. Work with in-house counsel.

Finally, if your company is threatened with litigation, involve in-house counsel as soon as possible. In-house counsel can grasp the details of claims against your company and help you make the best decisions to protect your business. 

Tatango Can Help With TCPA Requirements

Tatango has been an industry leader since 2007. Our text message marketing platform includes features designed to help you meet TCPA consent requirements to reduce your risk of litigation. Stay informed of TCPA regulations with our TCPA Survival Guide to ensure all of your SMS campaigns are protected.

Customer success

A named Customer Success Manager for every account.

Every account gets a Customer Success Manager you can call, who partners with your team from onboarding through election night to build effective campaigns and raise the ROI on every send. Our CS team is the part of Tatango customers review highest.

Fast, guided onboarding

Your CSM gets your numbers registered, integrations connected, and first send out on your timeline, then stays on the account.

Number registration · Integrations · First send

Campaign strategy and compliance guidance

Message cadence, segment strategy, ask amounts, consent and opt-out setup, quiet hours, and registration, reviewed with you before launch and as the cycle changes. Guidance, not legal advice.

Cadence · Segments · Consent · Carrier rules

Campaign-cycle coverage

Extended support through deadline nights, debates, and election week, with a person who already knows your program picking up the phone.

Deadline nights · Debates · Election week

Trust and security

Trust that holds up to scrutiny.

Security, privacy, and compliance controls audited independently and built into the platform, so a committee treasurer, compliance counsel, or data lead can sign off quickly.

SOC 2 Type II

Independently audited security controls, with a clean opinion for 2025.

HIPAA

HIPAA-ready controls and BAAs for organizations that handle protected health information alongside political or advocacy work.

TCPA controls

Consent capture, automatic opt-out handling, list scrubbing before every send, and exportable audit history.

10DLC and short code registration

Registered with The Campaign Registry and carriers before your first send.

Encryption and access

Encryption in transit and at rest, role-based access, and audit logging on every action.

Privacy and data handling

Data retention controls, isolated opt-out lists per organization, and a published trust center.

Read the trust center

See it on your program.

A 30-minute walkthrough tailored to fundraising, mobilization, or both.