Home
Resources
TCPA reference library
Case review: Fisher v. Alarm.com
Enforcement and cases

Case review: Fisher v. Alarm.com

2021 · 3 min
Case summary written in 2021. The outcome may have changed since.
This summarises litigation as it stood when it was written. Cases settle, get appealed, and get decided after the fact, so treat this as background on how a TCPA argument was framed rather than as the current state of the law or of this matter. Check the docket, and ask counsel before relying on any of it. How the obligations are structured

Summary of Fisher v. Alarm.com

Many brands have faced lawsuits for allegedly violating the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). The TCPA governs text and telephone marketing issues and requires marketers to obtain consent from consumers before contacting them. If an entity violates these rules, they can face fines of up to $1,500 per text or call. 

Nick Fisher brought a lawsuit against Alarm.com for multiple unsolicited marketing calls. Alarm.com sells home security products, and Fisher claimed to have been contacted without his consent. In cases like this one, the brand is usually held liable for violating TCPA rules. However, in this instance, the judge dismissed the case finding that Alarm.com wasn’t liable and Fisher hadn’t alleged enough to tie the calls directly to Alarm.com. The case involves marketing calls rather than SMS messages, but the lessons carry over. 

Who Is Liable?

Under TCPA rules, a carrier or brand is liable for calls or messages sent from the company or by a marketing firm they’ve hired. When a person is acting under a principal party, the principal party is legally responsible. For example, if a FedEx driver breaks the law and damages someone’s personal property, FedEx (not the individual employee) could face a lawsuit. A company can also be sued if one of its contractors or hired firms breaks the law. 

In Fisher v. Alarm.com, the situation was different. Fisher’s complaint didn’t plausibly allege that the calls were made on Alarm.com’s behalf or under their direction. These calls had been made by individuals unrelated to Alarm.com who were looking to sell Alarm.com’s products. For the TCPA to be enforced, a brand must be found to have agency and control over the callers themselves. The details in this case were murky, so the judge dismissed the case, and Alarm.com was not held liable. 

Why Is Fisher v. Alarm.com Important?

Due to the TCPA’s regulations, most brands consider themselves automatically liable for unsolicited contact with consumers. Fisher v. Alarm.com shows why it pays to examine the details and hire a TCPA attorney to help determine true liability. The grey areas of the law are difficult to understand and costly to navigate, especially with SMS messages, where fines can add up so quickly. 

Since your brand could be liable in possible lawsuits if mistakes occur under your direction, always do your research and work with reputable marketing firms and contractors who will maintain your high standards. We also recommend working with TCPA experts to market effectively while staying compliant with the laws. You’ll save money and protect your company in the long run. 

Meet TCPA Requirements With Tatango

Tatango has been an industry leader since 2007. Our text message marketing platform offers tools to help ensure you’re TCPA compliant. Alongside your attorney, our team of experts can help: contact us today to get started.

Customer success

A named Customer Success Manager for every account.

Every account gets a Customer Success Manager you can call, who partners with your team from onboarding through election night to build effective campaigns and raise the ROI on every send. Our CS team is the part of Tatango customers review highest.

Fast, guided onboarding

Your CSM gets your numbers registered, integrations connected, and first send out on your timeline, then stays on the account.

Number registration · Integrations · First send

Campaign strategy and compliance guidance

Message cadence, segment strategy, ask amounts, consent and opt-out setup, quiet hours, and registration, reviewed with you before launch and as the cycle changes. Guidance, not legal advice.

Cadence · Segments · Consent · Carrier rules

Campaign-cycle coverage

Extended support through deadline nights, debates, and election week, with a person who already knows your program picking up the phone.

Deadline nights · Debates · Election week

Trust and security

Trust that holds up to scrutiny.

Security, privacy, and compliance controls audited independently and built into the platform, so a committee treasurer, compliance counsel, or data lead can sign off quickly.

SOC 2 Type II

Independently audited security controls, with a clean opinion for 2025.

HIPAA

HIPAA-ready controls and BAAs for organizations that handle protected health information alongside political or advocacy work.

TCPA controls

Consent capture, automatic opt-out handling, list scrubbing before every send, and exportable audit history.

10DLC and short code registration

Registered with The Campaign Registry and carriers before your first send.

Encryption and access

Encryption in transit and at rest, role-based access, and audit logging on every action.

Privacy and data handling

Data retention controls, isolated opt-out lists per organization, and a published trust center.

Read the trust center

See it on your program.

A 30-minute walkthrough tailored to fundraising, mobilization, or both.