Start with the calendar, not the feature list
Most vendor comparisons start with a grid of checkmarks. That is the wrong end. Start with the two or three nights this cycle where the whole list has to hear from you inside an hour, because those nights are what separate platforms that look alike on a feature grid.
A filing deadline, a debate, an election eve push. If your program has them, throughput is your first question and everything else is secondary. If it does not, you can optimise for cost and start faster.
Ask what the throughput actually is, on your number type
Every vendor will say sends are fast. Ask for the number, on the number type you would actually run, and ask how long a send to a list your size takes end to end.
A dedicated short code clears high volume quickly because carriers treat it as a known, vetted sender. A registered 10-digit number costs less and starts faster, and its throughput is subject to carrier-imposed limits. Both deliver. The difference is minutes, and minutes are the whole game on a deadline.
Ask what happens to a message that does not arrive
This is the question that separates vendors fastest, and almost nobody asks it.
A carrier returns a delivery receipt for every message. A platform can surface that receipt with a reason when something fails, or it can roll failures into an average and show you a percentage. If a vendor cannot show you why an individual message failed, they are reporting an estimate.
Ask to see the failure view in the demo, not the success dashboard.
Treat any open rate as a red flag
Carriers do not report opens. There is no open event in SMS. A vendor quoting a 98 or 99 percent open rate is reporting an estimate as a measurement, and you should ask them directly where the number comes from.
What is actually measured is delivery, clicks on tracked links, replies, opt-outs, and contributions attributed to a message. Those are the numbers to compare between vendors, because those are the numbers that exist.
Ask how a gift gets connected to a message
For a fundraising program this is the deciding capability, and implementations vary more than the sales pages suggest.
The mechanism matters: campaign parameters passed through to your fundraising platform so the contribution comes back carrying the message and segment that produced it. Ask whether gifts that arrive hours after the send still get attributed, and ask whether you can see and argue with the match logic.
Also confirm who processes the money. On most political platforms, including this one, contributions are processed on your fundraising platform and the texting vendor attributes them.
Ask who files your registration, and when
Nothing sends until your brand and campaign are registered with The Campaign Registry and the carriers. Some vendors file it for you; some hand you a form.
Ask who does the filing, what they need from you, and what happens if the registry comes back with questions. Then ask for a realistic window rather than a best case, and build it into your launch plan. Any vendor promising a guaranteed date is promising something they do not control.
Ask what the compliance controls actually do
Consent capture, automatic opt-out handling, list scrubbing before every send, delivery by each recipient's time zone, and exportable audit history are the working parts. Ask to see the audit export, because that is the artifact your compliance counsel will want and the one most likely to be missing.
Be clear-eyed about what a platform can and cannot give you. It can give you controls and records. It cannot make your program compliant, and it is not legal advice. A vendor claiming otherwise is overselling.
Ask who answers the phone on election night
Support model is not a soft consideration in a cycle. Ask whether you get a named person who knows your program or a ticket queue, and ask specifically what coverage looks like on a deadline night, a debate night, and election week.
Ask what onboarding includes: who connects your integrations, who files registration, who is on the first send.
Check the integrations you actually run
A generic integrations page is not an answer. Name your fundraising platform and your CRM and ask what specifically moves, in which direction, and how often.
For most political programs the list is ActBlue or WinRed, a campaign CRM such as NGP VAN or EveryAction, and sometimes an advocacy platform. Confirm whether custom fields come across, because segmentation is only as good as the fields you can filter on.
Understand what A2P can and cannot reach
Application-to-person broadcast is opt-in only. The reachable audience is your own file: donors, supporters, keyword opt-ins. It is not a purchased persuasion universe, and any vendor implying otherwise is describing something else.
That constraint is also the strength. In-district reach is a property of the file rather than a modelled estimate, and every message returns a receipt.
How Tatango answers these
We built this list from the questions campaigns actually ask us, so it is fair to say where we land. Short code and 10DLC are both live and you can run both. Every message returns a carrier delivery receipt and failures are reported with a reason. We do not publish an open rate, because there is not one to publish. Gift attribution runs through campaign parameters passed to ActBlue, WinRed, Anedot, Revv and Fundraise Up, including gifts that land later. Registration is filed by our onboarding team. Every account gets a named Customer Success Manager. Sending is United States only.
Ask us the same questions you ask everyone else, and ask for the failure view.
A 30-minute walkthrough tailored to fundraising, mobilization, or both.
Common questions
Is political texting different from nonprofit texting?+
Yes. Consent rules, carrier registration use cases, and the cadence of the calendar all differ. Everything on this site is written for political and advocacy programs.
Do I need a short code?+
Not always. Short codes carry a lease fee and faster throughput, which a full-list deadline send needs; 10DLC starts faster and costs less. Your Customer Success Manager recommends the fit on a demo call.